Audit round 5 (curation feature): 5 blind reviewers, 14 confirmed fixes
The standing post-feature audit over a7f0cfe. Correctness (data): splits
become photo-scoped store records so splitting one edition no longer
force-splits same-named editions, and renaming a split copy migrates its
protection to the corrected title instead of silently re-merging copies.
Correctness (web): edit scoping now counts siblings by NORMALIZED title
(matching how stored edits apply), same-title-same-photos edits are
refused rather than corrupting the sibling entry, split copies serve
their real per-photo cues to the edit form instead of blanks, and a
split whose row vanished underneath returns 409 instead of a false 200.
Silent failures: replay_titles refuses to rebuild from a PARTIAL raw
cache (fresh clone + one --only extract would have truncated the
committed titles.json); the edit endpoint writes in crash-safe order
(cull, record, replay); corrupt curation stores fail loud naming the
file; retried edits don't double-record. Review-decision durability:
drop_rows never drops dedupe_veto rows — a rename retitles them in
place — and writes through a no-reload path so a concurrent rewrite
can't silently discard the cull. Style: catalog action cells get their
own class (.rowactions' flex display broke table alignment), editor
inputs match the design system and stop overriding the global
focus-visible outline, EditBody's clear-semantics docstring scoped to
cue fields, "nothing to change" derived from the record itself.
Tests: 8 new (photo-scoped splits, veto preservation, photo-narrowed
drops, 409s on both curation endpoints under a running job, partial-raw
replay guard, rename-keeps-protection lifecycle, corrupt-store error,
cue-field editing) and the dead edition_hint key in the edit test now
exercises real cue fields. 259 passing.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016jXZFSTZQKzAC8fqpWSz9g
This commit is contained in:
@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ Full design lives in `bgg-shelf-pipeline-spec.md` (read it before changing pipel
|
||||
- Base game vs. expansion vs. new edition is the top failure mode — bias matching toward `ambiguous` over auto-match ("Wingspan Europe" must not match base Wingspan).
|
||||
- Editions/versions matter: Eric owns multiple editions of some games — each is a separate collection entry (keyed by `collid` on BGG). Never guess a version: no legible cues → `version_unknown` and a version-less collection entry.
|
||||
- Normalize titles (casefold, strip punctuation/articles, special chars like é/&/:) identically on both sides of a match; dedupe across photos but keep `source_photos` provenance.
|
||||
- **Human curation is durable**: `data/title_splits.json` (titles split into per-photo copies) and `data/title_edits.json` (corrected reads/cues) are replayed on every titles.json rebuild, and both extract's and resolve's dedupe honor them forever. Row-level split decisions also persist via the `dedupe_veto` column.
|
||||
- **Human curation is durable**: `data/title_splits.json` (photo-scoped split-into-copies decisions, honored by extract's dedupe AND resolve's dedupe) and `data/title_edits.json` (corrected reads/cues, applied before dedupe on every titles.json rebuild) persist forever. Row-level decisions persist via the `dedupe_veto` column — edits never drop veto'd rows (a rename retitles them in place).
|
||||
- **RPGs are local-only citizens**: when the board-game search runs dry, resolve falls back to `type=rpgitem` (same geekdo API/token). Matched rpgitems enrich into the library but diff routes them to `local_only` — they must never reach `to_add.csv`/upload (their collection lives on RPGGeek, out of scope).
|
||||
- Detailed BGG API behavior (202 queueing, collection-endpoint quirks, endpoints): use the `bgg-api` skill. **If the spec's BGG behavior changes, update the `bgg-api` skill to match** — they must not drift.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user